Property Rights
Sometimes there's a conflict between property owners and the communities where their land is located. Local governments concerned about the quality of life in their communities sometimes come up with master plans that preserve a certain amount of open space around developed areas. Many communities feel they have benefited from such civic actions in that they enjoy fresher air and beautiful scenery nearby whereas some communities are so built up that they are classic examples of Suburban Sprawl. Some land owners, however, think that these plans and other ordinances that limit the use of their land (including enactment wide riparian setbacks for the rivers and streams that flow through their land) and infringe on their property rights as landowners.
Individualism is strong in the American culture. We don't particularly like to be told what to do with our land or anything else. But we do realize that we have to live together and compromise to ensure that our communities survive. It isn't always easy.
Some property owners combine their resources and attempt to get legislation of their own passed. One example is the "Fair Payment for Public Benefit Act" proposed by a group of landowners in Napa County, California, called the Napa Valley Land Stewards Alliance. Their basic premise is that if a local government enacts an ordinance that secures public benefit (such as preserving salmon habitat in a local river) that infringes on their use and ability to profit from their land, the public should compensate the landowner for such benefit.
Not so fast, say their opponents. Legislation that has preserved agricultural land and protected wildlife has actually led to dramatic increases in land values as well as a thriving local wine industry known the world over. None of this would have been possible without the protective measures taken by local government. So, they say landowners are already receiving benefits and do not deserve further compensation.
The Napa Valley Land Stewards Alliance points out, however, that they are not trying to undo all the good things that have been done for preserving agricultural land and the environment to date. And they do not want to be compensated for past actions that have limited the use of their land. (Limiting land use is actually a commonly accepted thing. All communities have zoning laws that determine how portions of land within their boundaries can be used.) The alliance says they simply feel the government has done enough, and no more such protective measures need to be put in place. However, if the government sees things differently, and they pass measures that infringe on their property rights, the landowners want to be paid for their loss of use of the parts of their land affected.
Who's right? That will be up to Napa voters to decide.
Property Rights related articles:
Psychology Major
The diverse system of education today has much to offer in terms of majors and minors. Whether we choose engineering or accounting doesn’t seem to be an issue. However, there are other branches of education that pose certain concerns in the “real world,... Quilting Designs
There are some who make a strong connection between gardening and quilting. The two activities are very traditional and homey. One of the reasons that the two have such a deep connection could lie in the changing seasons each year. Avid gardeners may feel... Relationships
The first date you go on with someone seems so important, right? Your palms are sweaty, you are hoping that he or she will be "the one," and your are trying so hard to make a good first impression. First dates are, ideally, the seed that will grow into a ... Remote Control Car
Remote Control Car
Over the holidays, good friends of ours drove to Grand Forks, which is just a couple of hours away, and just on the other side of the Canadian/American border. They wanted to take advantage of the fantastic post-Christmas sales... Research Papers Online
You may be searching for research papers online because you legitimately need to see samples, models, by which to write your own piece. You may be drilling down through the labyrinth of research papers online to compare writing styles or to price the mos...
more Pocket Links articles:
Harley Davidson Factory
Harley-Davidson Factory
Harley-Davidson has come a long way since William S. Harley drew the first blueprint of a motor designed to fit into a bicycle in 1901. Here’s just a little bit of the history according to www.harley-davidson.com. When he ... Natural Weight Loss
Technology has certainly catered to many of our daily struggles. Plastic surgery is no small cog in our machine of simplicity. More and more people are taking advantage of surgery's aesthetic benefits. One of the major desires controlling our society i... Mountain Cabins For Rent
Mountain Cabins for Rent
If you are planning to visit the mountains you may want to consider renting a mountain cabin instead of a hotel or motel. In most mountainous resort areas across the country there are mountain cabins for rent in a variety... Create Your Own Website
Are you computer savvy? For the longest time I would have said that computers were surely not my forte. However, these days I'm not so sure. I mean, I know how to bank online; I surf the web daily; I know how to use Microsoft office, I comprehend gigabyte... Gaming Pc
Although console video game systems seem to be all the rage today, and as a whole dominate the gaming market, the PC remains the single most popular platform for games. With by far the largest selection of games available, an avid video game lover should... |